OK—two disclaimers and an FYI:
1. If you get queasy this one might not be for you. There are descriptions and even pictures of a small but significant wound on my finger included in this post.
2. I am fully aware that a finger and a uterus are different from each other, I’m using my finger in this post as an inspiration to consider uterine scars and how they heal. I also talk a bit about airplanes and the scientists who understand why they fly—and I relate them to the scientists (physicians) who understand cesarean surgery. You can ignore the finger and airplane parts and the rest of this will still make sense : )
FYI: there are some highlighted phrases in this post–they are live links, click on them to learn more!
For the rest of y’all….
It has been with a great deal of interest that I have observed my own finger over the last two months. It all started with that magic moment I felt the lid of the tin can I was opening make a neat “pop” sound as it cut into the soft skin just below the first knuckle of my pointer finger on my right hand. It was followed quickly by a series of thoughts in my head that went something like this:
Me: “hey, I just cut my finger”
Me Again: “wow, I think that’s my bone”
Me: “oh, my, that’s cool”
Me Again: “um, I think that’s my bone”
Me: “hmmm. I think I’m gonna pass out.”
Me Again: “Why would I pass out, remember the crazy things I’ve seen—way worse than this!”
Me: “yah, stop talking and lie down on the floor and put your feet up before you faint”
As I slumped to the floor, spine removed from body style, I quietly said to my husband, “Hey, I think I just cut myself really badly”. Here’s a picture of the cut:

I went to the doctor. This cut went through several layers of skin and tissue. It was kinda nasty. But, thanks to old timey medicine, I got it sewn up. I had five interrupted stitches placed in this cut. Here’s a picture of the stitches:

So sexy, right?!
Remember, this is just my finger. But it’s my finger. These little suckers throb like the dickens when they’ve been thumped, sliced, burned, or otherwise assaulted. I found I needed my finger for all sorts of daily tasks, and anytime I put any pressure on it or near it I would feel the pull of the stitches and the associated burning. Goodbye sleep, I tossed and turned all night for several nights trying to make my finger comfortable! It was kind of rude. But as I lay awake in the wee hours I started to think about the other scars I’ve known. The scars that belong to these women we have loved through hours of prenatal discussions and long nights of labor as they walked the long path to birthing a child vaginally after a cesarean birth. Of my own scar from my first birth, and how much that birth established me in this world. And the two births I had where my lovely boys sailed right past that scar on their way to my arms. I imagine them looking at it from the inside and I remember my doubts about whether or not that scar would need to be reopened in order for them to be born. For the record, I was over 42 weeks with both of those boys before they were born. My scar stayed closed. It neither burst open on its own nor did anyone slice back into it to birth the boys. That may seem odd at first glance. I mean, let’s review. See that wee little cut up there on my finger? Why on earth would a few threads actually work so that my finger won’t split open every time I try to wash a dish in the future? And why on earth did the scar on my uterus not split open just from carrying the weight of the baby, the amniotic fluid, and the placenta, let alone from the pressure of labor?
I’ve often challenged my father-in-law the aerospace engineer to really explain to me why a giant metal machine full of parts, baggage, and people would possibly stay up in the air. He patiently explains things likes “fluid mechanics” and “aerodynamics” and, no pun intended, it flies right over my head every single time. But here’s the thing: if you Google “how does an airplane stay in the air?” you will get roughly two million, seven hundred thousand answers. Rocket scientists are not gatekeepers. They want to share what they know even though it requires sharing of scientific and often complicated ideas. Amazingly, when, in the middle of the night, I wondered, “hey, how many stitches does it take to close a cesarean?”, and I googled it, the answer proved to be non-existent online. I was trying to equate trusting my finger to work again with trusting a uterus to work again. Although I’ve had my own cesarean, and seen dozens and dozens of them, I don’t know even approximately how many stitches it takes to close up that wound. I do know there are five layers of stitches (the wall and outer lining of the uterus, the rectus muscle, fascia, and finally the ones that are visible to close the outer layer). When I (just now) asked my OB friend for an answer he shared that he uses about seven lengths of sutures and extra if there is additional bleeding or a longer than average cut. Each suture length is 18 inches long, making just over ten feet of suture material that goes into closing up the incision for a cesarean birth. When you are thinking of that magic combination of the body’s ability to heal and natural surge towards health and the support for that process given by sutures, you might see in your mind’s eye why those layers of incisions come together so well.
The really important part of this discovery is not that the information is not readily available online, it is the kind of phrases I saw that are online. In answer to my question, one many women seem to have posed over many a web site, you can find answers such as, “I asked my doctor but he told me there about 10 staples on the outer-most layer and since that’s all I can see it is all I should worry about”. And then there is the physician who condescends, “Personally, I would not worry about this and would trust the surgeon to do the best and place trust for your best!” Huh? If the repair, recovery, and future strength and functionability of the organ which sustains and then gives us actual life is guarded more than the secrets of how to fly an airplane, it’s no wonder we don’t know if we can trust it!
As two wise women, in their upcoming book The Essential Homebirth Guide have been known to say, “The Big Bad Wolf of the VBAC question is uterine rupture”…but what is a big bad wolf? A mysterious allegorical shadow that gains darkness when we think about it because what we can’t define, we tend to fear. Fear is not released just because a very nice person in a white coat pats our backs and coos, “ah, don’t you just worry your pretty little head about it”. Understanding and knowledge allow us to let go of our fears. Knowledge of how wounds heal, what to expect as your incision heals, and how it will all hold together during your next pregnancy, labor, and birth can put to rest a large percentage of the fear many women carry with them from one birth to the next. A huge thank you to the prolific writer Robin Elise Weiss who covers all things pregnancy for about.com. Click here and you can take a tour of photos of all-things cesarean-scar related. And of course to the steady source of support and information, we turn to ICAN at this link to get the frank details of exactly what occurs in a cesarean surgery.
So what’s in a finger? And how on earth can we use my once sliced and now healed finger to guide us in our thoughts about uterine scars? And what voice will we use to replace the dude in our heads who is going on about how we should just be nice girls and trust our doctors to do what is right?
Here is my finger today:

Here are some of the things I am doing every day with my finger: washing my hair, holding my toothbrush, typing, writing, pointing, carrying, chopping, sautéing, washing dishes, cleaning counters, petting the dog. Also, I tend to feel my scar a lot and massage it and say nice things to it like, “thank you so much for healing, my life is so much easier now that you are all closed up!” I couldn’t use my finger for all of the activities it was designed to help me accomplish for quite a while. But now it is healed, and I get to use it again.
When I meet a woman who is considering a VBAC, and for example I met one yesterday and 3 last week, I look at my finger. That scar and all of the tissue beneath it are really strong. I trust it to do all of the activities it was designed to do. I trust it for many reasons. And now I get to add that I trust it because I got to watch how a combination of my body’s natural prowess at healing and some well placed sutures worked together to create a very strong bond where a wide open gap once existed. And that is exactly why I carried and birthed two babies, both born a full pound to pound and a half larger than their older sister, without worrying about my uterus suddenly splitting in two. The research backs up my observation and experience, and as midwives or a doulas, or whatever kind of birth worker label you want to slap on us, that is why Jane and I trust that the biggest worry in the room where a VBAC mother is busy being pregnant or birthing should never be whether or not her body, which has done the work of healing just like my finger, will suddenly split open.
And now a word about that booming voice and how nice girls oughtta act and show reverence for what the doc says. There are a handful of hospital-based midwifery and OB practices around Seattle that require a mom planning to VBAC to have a visit with the “high risk” obstetrician to be “approved” for a VBAC. They are using a variety of parameters to decide whether or not to allow a woman to labor and deliver vaginally according to her wishes (they are different from practice to practice). They are not using World Health Organization recommendations, or the recommendations of their own agency (ACOG), or good science, or best practice. They are not comparing the risks of second surgical births to a vaginal birth. They are using arbitrary lines in the cement, likely based on policy created by reactive attorneys for their hospitals (this is just the society we live in today—it may or may not be something that the OB actually believes to be true). After all of the years of watching cesarean rates rise, and VBAC rates rise, then fall, and now slowly creep up again, we are down to waiting and praying silently for approval or denial that may or may not be grounded in the truth about a woman’s body and her baby. Enough with the good-girls, it’s time to get smart and learn about what keeps your uterus from falling apart at the first contraction. Join ICAN today, follow the evidence, get yourself with a midwife or a physician who looks at you as if you are capable, smart, and able to understand science and logic. Then celebrate your strong healthy uterus every single day. From my fully functioning finger to your glorious capable and monstrously successful uterus, may we all enjoy the thrill of knowledge and the confidence born of understanding the truth about how our bodies heal.